Cloverdale Elementary School held a carnival on Saturday evening before Halloween, 1972. My friend Bill and I attended, along with lots of parents and elementary school kids.
Ninth graders at Cloverdale Junior High at the time, we felt so much more mature and thereby superior than all the elementary schoolers. We were not deceived for more than a few minutes by the spaghetti brains with grape eyeballs.
At one point, we were presented a mop handle with a clothespin dangling from the end with twine. The clothespin was lowered over a bed sheet draped across a corner of the room. Soon there was a little tug on the string and voila, a “fish” was caught in the clothes pin.
Everyone received a brown paper bag of assorted treasures including pencils, erasers, and trinkets that, like Cinderella’s coach, reverted to trash at midnight.
Afterwards, we strolled to the Burger King for some cheap eats and a chance to examine our Halloween goodies. We sat on stools lined up against the front wall of the restaurant, which was a floor-to-ceiling window.
A policeman was standing outside a few feet away, looking properly stern, especially when he saw long-haired, adolescent trouble-makers pretending to be innocent, law-abiding fast-food patrons.
Bill took a cellophane-like Pizza Hut Pete hand puppet from his bag and stuck it on his right hand. In a high, squeaky voice, he proceeded to entertain me with droll remarks such as the evergreen “Hey, who farted?”
We were just shy of laughing so hard Coke shot from our noses when the cop stormed in. He ripped the plastic puppet from Bill’s hand like Velma unmasking a Scooby-Doo villain.
Giving us the evil eye, he growled, “I’m gonna throw you both in jail if you don’t stop this shit right now!”
Bill and I were shocked. Was it okay to say “shit” in Burger King?
The only thing we could possibly be doing wrong was having hair too long for this guy, whose idea of fashion-forward was a flat-top haircut you could land a PiperJet on.
Did Santa neglect to give him a puppet as a child?
Maybe he was sensitive to fart jokes due to uncontrollable flatulence?
After we left, we gradually recovered from our run-in with “the Man” with only minor psychological scarring. For example, I still cannot poop for a fortnight after eating a Whopper.
Glancing through the McClellan High yearbook during the COVID-19 epidemic, I noticed a curious thing. In a photo of the band, Bill is right at the end of a row. He is holding his trombone in a special manner, one not taught in beginner band class, a manner that could, just possibly, be construed as flipping the bird.
When asked about it, Bill told me that in his days as a Rebel Without a Clue, he often surreptitiously flashed the finger. With only cursory research, I found other yearbook photos showcasing his single digit salute.
While still sequestered from the infectious world, I also indulged some nostalgic purchases via eBay. Those included a risqué paperback about flight attendants called Coffee, Tea or Me?, a Farrell’s Ice Cream Parlour menu from 1973, a pair of vintage 1970 “two tone disco groovy platform hippie shoes”, and a Pizza Hut hand puppet just like the one from the brown paper bag.
It was maybe a year later when I awoke at 3:00 am, my brain bristling with a sudden and peculiar idea.
I hurried downstairs to The Official Steve Hendricks Archives and yanked out the 1972 volume where I stored the hand puppet. I verified my nocturnal suspicion.
With this latest clue, could I finally solve a mystery from the days before Michael Jackson’s balls dropped?
Some months later, I stopped in to visit Bill and his delightful wife Lisa. I told them about the Burger King Halloween Mystery. Their little gray cells figured it all out long before I revealed the solution, spoiling my shot at a Hercule Poirot moment.
That earlier night, when I had checked out the fevered idea that had awakened me, I learned that the Pizza Hut hand puppet had a clear plastic back…
The kind of transparent back that allowed Bill, unseen and unsuspected by me, to “innocently” flip off the cop. While we laughed like demented hyenas sniffing nitrous oxide!
It had been a bad idea on his part, especially in Arkansas, doubly so in the early 1970s, when many police officers had their sense of humor surgically replaced with racial intolerance.
Luckily for us, we were young and so white we were practically translucent.
After taking 50 years to solve this perplexing puzzle, I await an answer from Scotland Yard regarding my offer to look into the Jack the Ripper murder spree.
I’m sure I can prove that a puppet had a hand in it.




















